The Suncorp-Vero/HIA consumer protection
scheme |
compared to Queensland's BSA Scheme |
Prepared
by Builders Collective Australia Inc. |
New South
Wales scheme overseen by Office of Fair Trading and operated
privately by Suncorp/Vero Insurance Company |
Queensland
scheme operated by the Queensland Government through the Building Services Authority |
Last Resort
Max P/out $300,000 but limited to
20% of the original contract value for non - completion |
First Resort Max P/out $400,000.00 No limits!
and includes the effects of subsidence or settlement |
| Comments
sourced from the OFT web site at: http://www.fairtrading.nsw.gov.au/
|
Comments sourced from
the BSA website at: http://www.bsa.qld.gov.au/Home/Default.htm
|
Responsible Minister:
Fair Trading The Hon. Linda Jean Burney |
Responsible Minister:
Housing Minister Robert Schwarten |
| Beechwood
Homes Collapse 13th May 2008 |
Real
Property Constructions Collapse 8th Feb 2008 |
Impact - 300 un-completed
homes and 400 deposits paid |
Impact
‚ 233 un-completed homes and 87 deposits paid |
14th
May. Minister
Burney urged clients of
|
The
BSA opened across the weekend with 26 staff to contact affected consumers
and advise them BSA administers an insurance fund (called
the ìQueensland Home Warranty Schemeî) which provides a benefit for
specified losses associated with a contractorís failure to complete
a contract. If work has commenced, the insurance benefit
is, (subject to the terms and conditions of the policy), equal to the
cost to complete the works, less any moneys you are still holding under
your contract. If work has not commenced, the insurance benefit is limited to, (subject to the terms and conditions of the policy), a refund of deposit paid. |
15th
May. Vero
has recognised the company as insolvent following the appointment of
a receiver. Vero
regards this as the trigger for consumers to lodge claims for home warranty
insurance a claim under the Home building Act |
|
16th May.
Minister Burney calls
for calm ìIt is important that
anyone with a contract with Beechwood Homes does not cancel it. |
|
| 23rd May.
ìProgress is being made
to find a buyer to take over the Beechwood contracts. ìIn
the event that Beechwood is not sold, the home warranty insurer Vero
has indicated that it is ready to get on with the job of having the
homes completedî. |
|
26th May. Ms Burney said that Vero
has sent claim forms to all Beechwood Homes policy holders last week. ìMy office has been in
contact with Vero about having these claims processed as quickly as
possible,î Ms Burney said. |
|
2nd June I know that the families
who have suffered from the collapse of Beechwood are experiencing awful
stress,î Ms Burney said. ìI want to reassure people
that rectifying the situation will take a bit more time but it will
get sorted.î |
|
3rd
June Beechwood victims told to wait VICTIMS
of the collapsed building company Beechwood Homes face a further
three- to four-week delay in the resumption of construction of their
homes because ... |
6th
May. About 70% of clients
affected by the failure of Sunshine Coast-based Real Property Constructions
have had their homes completed or deposits refunded. Mr
Schwarten said all 207 complaints received by the Building Services
Authority about RPC had been assessed and 140 finalised. ìThere are
35 jobs currently out to tender and another 13 have been sent to quoting
builders,î he said ìHomeowners
affected by RPCís collapse just three months ago, the BSA
has done a great job in finalising about 70% of peopleís claims.î Mr
Schwarten said the value of claims under the warranty insurance scheme
to date was $1.9 million. |
24th May Beechwood
home buyers told not to pay progress payments Ms Burney criticised the receiver for
issuing progress payment bills to home ownersÖÖ Consumer meeting Anguish hits home ÖÖ. No
one to call when roof falls in The controversy over "worthless" mandatory home building warranty
insurance ragesÖ.. NSW
govt's Beechwood handling under fire Insurance
threat driving builders away Bills
stop for builder's victims 31st May Beechwood bell tolls for everyone One South Coast concreter and a plumber
are owed $500,000 eachÖÖÖ. Questions
over $200000 claim paid to Coonan 9th June Senate
attacks housing's 'junk insurance' scheme With the HIAís Ron Silberberg dismissing
the inquiry as a "kangaroo court". Rebuff
for Senate on building insurance 10th June Hundreds
more may be hit by collapse Being those 580 that
were having plans done at a cost of between $2,500 & $5,000 by Beechwood
but without a contract or warranty in place so no insurance applies
11th June Choice
urges states to overhaul home warranty insurance 19th June Receiver
rejects call to release home
plan VICTIMS
of the Beechwood Homes collapse seeking to cut their losses and start
from scratch have been told by the company's receiver they do not own
the house plans they have paid for. |
6th May 2008
http://www.thedaily.com.au/news/2008/may/06/relief-clients-rpc/ About
70% of clients affected by the failure of Sunshine Coast-based Real
Property Constructions have had their homes completed or deposits refunded.
|
6th July 2008 Beechwood
sale still up in the air UP TO 1000 families and builders remain uncertain about the
future of collapsed builder Beechwood Homes. |
|
12th July 2008 Beechwood
homes victims get ray of hope |
|
21st July 2008 Beechwood sale deadline not today: Govt |
|
28th July 2008 Beechwood
Homes site reopens for business |
|
29th July 2008 BEECHWOOD Homes, the collapsed NSW home-builder,
has been sold to a family-owned business, Cavasinni Constructions. Beechwood receivers Deloitte today
said the business had been sold for an undisclosed amount with all assets,
including existing land, buildings, contracts and copyright. |
|
30th July 2008 Beechwood
homes in new hands |
|
Now
that Beechwood has been sold it would appear the warranty insurance
scheme will not/may not apply in this instance and the homes will be
finished under the existing contracts. If this is the case that may
be a great scenario for the consumers if their homes are finished for
the original contracted price, however that outcome remains to be seen. The QBSA failure on
the 8th Feb 2008 saw the instant implementation of their
first resort warranty scheme and after only 12 weeks saw 70% of consumer
claims satisfied. This is the scheme we have been advocating since
the HIH collapse. In an industry big enough that we measure the fiscal health
on the nation on we are being made look as though we are all a bunch
of rat bags, incapable of managing our industry and providing basic
consumer protection in a timely manner such as the holistic Qld scheme Both NSW and Victoria jointly introduced this BWI scheme back
in 2002 and appear to have an obsession to maintain the status quo in
the face of overwhelming evidence of its failure to provide anything
like appropriate consumer protection let alone anything that resembles
reasonable industry management so it would appear there can only be
one conclusion and that is that others are benefiting from its being. The responsible NSW Minister is the Hon. Linda Jean Burney
who has stated on numerous occasions that NSW has an effective consumer
protection framework which delivers protection for consumers who are
faced with the collapse of their builderís company. Thank you Minister, but where is the effective warranty
insurance protection? The Current Senate inquiry should represent both the consumers
and builders of this nation in this most serious of matters that has
seen suicide, financial failures, and family breakdowns suffered by
thousands of Australians, and yet the major supporters of the current
arrangements number only 2 from the big end of town being Vero Insurance
and the Housing Industry Association and they have refused to appear
before the Senate inquiry with the latter referring to the process as
a kangaroo court. This vexed and controversial issue has seem 35 inquires and
reviews over the past 10 years plus the Productivity Commission inquiry
handed down recently that described this warranty as a running sore
and now we have the Senate Inquiry that as yet has not compelled the
two pivotal players to appear before the committee at a public hearing. |
The Builders Collective of Australia (BCA) is the amalgamation of all the various groups
around the nation that formed in 2002 to fight the introduction of the
Last Resort scheme and
consisted of the NSW Be-Fair
builders group, the Builders Collective, Home Warranty Action Group (HWAG)
from the Illawarra region, the Central West Home Builders Scheme (CWHBS) from Orange, and
The Housing Indemnity Action Group (HIAG) together with the Builders (WA) mutual Fund Limited
(BMFL) both from Perth which had preliminary approval from the
WA Government for this proposed Mutual at this link www.buildersmutual.com.au The Builders Collective
of Australia Working for a better Building Industry 0414 699 905 |